A Closer Look at Yesterday’s Appellate Division Ruling on the Pied-à-Terre Tax

On November 4, 2026, in Matter of O’Brien v. City of New York (Index No. 85217/26), the Appellate Division, Second Department, reversed the September 29, 2026 New York Supreme Court decision that had invalidated the New York City Department of Finance’s (“DOF”) initial implementation of the pied-à-terre tax. The decision can be found HERE.

The lower court had previously ruled in favor of the property owners’ challenge to the DOF’s publication of property valuations and issuance of approximately 17,000 initial tax determination notices. The unanimous ruling by the Appellate Division reverses that judgment and removes the judicial relief previously granted against the DOF’s implementation procedures.

How the Court Ruled

The Appellate Division’s decision turned principally on the issue of standing, rather than a comprehensive determination of whether the DOF properly implemented the tax. The Court concluded that the property owners had failed to demonstrate a sufficiently concrete and particularized injury to maintain their challenge. Specifically, the Court held that inclusion on the DOF’s publicly available supplemental property valuation roll and receipt of an initial determination notice did not “impose an obligation, deny a right or fix some legal relationship”.

With respect to the property owners’ claims that the initial determination notices burdened taxpayers the Court stated “All taxpayers incur time, effort, and costs in determining and complying with their various tax obligations, which vary from person to person, entity to entity, and tax bracket to tax bracket, sometimes widely, depending on each taxpayer’s individualized circumstances within the broader federal, state, and local tax matrix. In any event, the petitioners have not documented and quantified any actual costs incurred.” 

Next Steps for the Tax

The appellate ruling permits the City’s statutory administrative process to proceed without the restrictions imposed by the lower court’s judgment. The ruling does not address the constitutionality of the tax which is being addressed in two separate actions:

• Robert Friedman et al v. The State of New York (complaint available HERE)
• Wilbur Louis Ross Jr. et al v. State of New York (complaint available HERE)

Taxpayers have until March 1, 2027 for Tax Class 2  properties (condos, co-ops, and multi-family buildings) and until March 15, 2027 for  Tax Class 1 properties (1-, 2-, and 3-family homes) to appeal any determination by the New York City Department of Finance to the Tax Commission. 
 

The foregoing is not intended to be comprehensive nor constitute legal advice. If you would like to discuss your specific circumstances or would like more information, feel free to contact us at (212) 625-8505.

Scroll to Top